In Estonia, cultural funding has traditionally relied heavily on public financing. But should this continue to be the case, and how can more private funding be attracted to the cultural sector? These questions are explored by our Counsel, Kärt Anna Maire Kelder, in Edasi.
Estonia’s public expenditure on culture is among the highest in Europe, amounting to approximately 3% of GDP. Given the size of existing public budgets, it is unlikely that significantly more state funding will be directed towards culture in the future. At the same time, these figures are partly influenced by the inclusion of major publicly funded institutions such as the national broadcaster and the Cultural Endowment of Estonia.
Private funding is receiving growing attention
As a result, many projects and creative ideas at both community and talent level remain underfunded, and attracting private capital has become an increasingly important topic. Estonia has the potential to deliver world-class cultural experiences and become a destination for both cultural tourism and international sporting events. However, achieving these ambitions will require greater private-sector involvement in funding culture.
At the beginning of last year, a study titled “Attracting Private Funding to Culture and Sport” was published.
The study found that support from private donors increased during the previous two years, partly due to the impact of the war in Ukraine. Estonian companies declared approximately EUR 42 million in gifts and donations in 2022. However, by 2023 corporate giving had returned to pre-2022 levels, amounting to around EUR 16.5 million.
Individual donations exceed corporate contributions
Perhaps surprisingly, the volume of donations made by private individuals is no lower than corporate giving. In 2023, individual donations totalled approximately EUR 32 million, nearly twice the amount donated by companies. At the same time, the data suggests that the number of donors is not increasing significantly, while the average size of donations is growing.
Charitable giving is voluntary by nature. People are motivated by a sense of purpose, confidence in the transparency and professionalism of the recipient organisation, and, in some cases, prestige. Interestingly, the study found that tax incentives are considered a relatively minor factor in encouraging private giving.
While the survey did not explore in detail whether this reflects a lack of awareness of tax incentives or concerns about their effectiveness, it concluded that awareness of available tax benefits remains relatively low.
Does the Estonian tax system support charitable giving?
One explanation for the limited importance attached to tax incentives may be that Estonia’s tax system has long been relatively straightforward and uniform, with few significant exceptions. In many other European countries, tax systems have evolved over decades and often contain complex and sometimes inconsistent mechanisms, with various incentives designed to mitigate their effects.
Sponsorship arrangements are also widely used. They allow support to be provided through marketing activities and treated as a business-related expense, meaning that the limits ordinarily applicable to donations do not apply.
Nevertheless, tax incentives play an important role in encouraging private giving. Their purpose is to influence behaviour, encouraging companies and individuals to support socially beneficial causes. The relationship between taxation and behaviour is well established in tax policy and legislation.
When traditional sponsorship and marketing arrangements are set aside, funding culture through donations may be preferable to funding it through commercial sponsorship. This is partly a matter of transparency, but also because sponsorship inevitably comes with commercial expectations. Marketing activities are intended to increase visibility and serve business interests. While sponsor logos naturally fit into sporting events and broadcast coverage, relatively few cultural projects offer comparable visibility, and creating a clear connection between a sponsor’s brand and a cultural event is often more difficult.
Donations provide a more neutral alternative. Because they are voluntary and do not involve receiving anything in return, they offer greater autonomy both for the donor and for the recipient organisation.
Individual giving should be encouraged in particular, as private donations allow community-level initiatives and smaller projects to be funded, create emotional engagement, enable direct feedback, and strengthen the connection between citizens, culture and the state.
If tax incentives are not seen as important, how can charitable giving be encouraged?
That remains the key question. While donors may not currently view tax benefits as a decisive factor, there appears to be significant potential to improve awareness, strengthen engagement and develop a stronger culture of private philanthropy.
Read the full article in Edasi: Read more